@natalie_ng said in Thoughts on California's new bill targeted towards only Asian-Americans?:
What about the ones that are legal and/or are born here?
The problem is you can’t talk about legal Hispanic citizens w/o also talking about illegal immigrants. The two are intertwined. 1st-gen immigrants tend to be illegal while their children are legal. Because of this makeup, families involve illegal immigrant parents who work under the table (these jobs may or may not pay bottom of the barrel) while children are legal. That allows them to access welfare, nutrition assistance and health-care.
I’m not exactly sure how well Hispanics do outside of Hispanic enclaves but here in AZ where there’s a significant population and where cost of living is lower, they’re actually not doing too bad here. 2nd generation moved up and getting some white-collar jobs. Not top of the line stuff, but it pays for life here well enough. 3rd-generation are going to college and supposedly Hispanics have the highest likelihood of going to college.
Poverty is a notable barrier and yes, it is SIMILAR to SEA’s problems but they’re poorer than whites and Asians. Remember that for many families, they came here as illegals and therefore the work that they do are under the table and may not be able to afford the same living as Asian-Americans. Asian Americans tend to be legal immigrants and therefore have access to higher paying jobs. Sure, SEA’s live on the low end, but the legal low end is higher than the illegal low end.
True, but you also said their culture/family values are also holding them back. In that sense, they are similar to SEAs/Hispanics.
Similar to Hispanic, but not Asian. Asian family values/culture are largely the same except that EA has middle-class values. All you’d have to do is install those values onto SEA parents and make it a smoother ride which will catapult SEA to the same levels as EA. Black/Hispanic culture/family values do not have middle-class values and black families tend to be more broken than Hispanic ones. Hispanic families are intact but tend to be poorer than whites/Asians. Both Black/Hispanic have a similar academic achievement levels.
I see. So is this the main trait that would differentiate SEAs from blacks/hispanics (and hence, enabling you to believe that they have more hope with governmental assistance programs than blacks/hispanics)?
Governmental assistance is not the end all be all. All races have access to governmental assistance already. It’s difficult to talk about Blacks and Hispanics b/c each race does not have the same problems and yes, we are different. To lump us all into the same category and dole out assistance across the board will not work.
then why should they worry about whether or not affirmative action will affect them?
They’re looking at the long term potential implications which means that it’s calculated and not an overreaction. An overreaction means that the bill has zero impact and affirmative action coming back has zero chance. The chance for affirmative action coming back is still there.